# Difference between revisions of "Boolean Algebra"

Marc Brown (talk | contribs) |
Marc Brown (talk | contribs) |
||

Line 1: | Line 1: | ||

''Boolean algebra''' is the branch of algebra in which the values of the | ''Boolean algebra''' is the branch of algebra in which the values of the variables and constants have exactly two values: "true" and "false", usually denoted 1 and 0 respectively. This overview is taken from the Wikipedia article. | ||

The main operations of Boolean algebra are "and" (conjunction), "or" (disjunction), and "not" (negation). The "and" operator says that two variable are true | The main operations of Boolean algebra are "and" (conjunction), "or" (disjunction), and "not" (negation). The "and" operator says that two variable are true only whenever both variables are true. The "or" operator says that two variables are true whenever either or both variables are true. The "not" operator changes a true to false and a false to true. Just as algebra has basic rules for simplifying and evaluating expression, so does Boolean algebra. | ||

Boolean algebra is important to programmers, computer scientists, and the general population. | Boolean algebra is important to programmers, computer scientists, and the general population. | ||

*For programmers, Boolean expressions are used for conditionals and loops. For example, the following snippet of code sums the even numbers that are not also multiples of 3, stopping when the sum hits 100: | |||

<syntaxhighlight lang="python"> | |||

s = 0 | |||

x = 1 | |||

while (s < 100): | |||

if (x % 2 == 0) and (x % 3 != 0): | |||

s = s + x | |||

x = x + 1 | |||

</syntaxhighlight> | |||

Both | |||

<syntaxhighlight lang="python" inline>s < 100</syntaxhighlight> | |||

and | |||

<syntaxhighlight lang="python" inline>(x % 2 == 0) and (x % 3 != 0)</syntaxhighlight>are Boolean expressions. | |||

*For computer scientists, Boolean algebra defines the circuits that make up the logic of digital computers. | |||

*The general population uses Boolean algebra, probably without knowing that they are doing so, when they enter search terms in Internet search engines. Google, | |||

for example, suuport AND, OR, and NOT, as well as a handful of shorthands (See e.g.,[https://www.google.com/help/cheatsheet.html Syntax cheatsheet], | |||

** Whitespace is used to specify logical AND, as it is the default operator for joining search terms: | |||

** The OR keyword is used for logical OR: | |||

**A prefixed minus sign is used for logical NOT: | |||

For example, the search team jaguar speed -car returns pages about the speed of the Jaquar animal. | |||

"Search term 1" −"Search term 2" | |||

<!-- (let's get this speculation resolved before including it in the article) | |||

* Parentheses do not appear to be supported for explicitly specifying the order of operations. | |||

==Operations== | ==Operations== | ||

Line 23: | Line 42: | ||

The basic operations of Boolean algebra are as follows: | The basic operations of Boolean algebra are as follows: | ||

* AND ([[Logical conjunction|conjunction]]), denoted ''x | * AND ([[Logical conjunction|conjunction]]), denoted ''x&y'' (sometimes ''x'' AND ''y'' or K''xy''), satisfies ''x''∧''y'' = 1 if ''x'' = ''y'' = 1 and ''x''∧''y'' = 0 otherwise. | ||

* OR ([[Logical disjunction|disjunction]]), denoted ''x''∨''y'' (sometimes ''x'' OR ''y'' or A''xy''), satisfies ''x''∨''y'' = 0 if ''x'' = ''y'' = 0 and ''x''∨''y'' = 1 otherwise. | * OR ([[Logical disjunction|disjunction]]), denoted ''x''∨''y'' (sometimes ''x'' OR ''y'' or A''xy''), satisfies ''x''∨''y'' = 0 if ''x'' = ''y'' = 0 and ''x''∨''y'' = 1 otherwise. | ||

* NOT ([[negation]]), denoted ¬''x'' (sometimes NOT ''x'', N''x'' or !''x''), satisfies ¬''x'' = 0 if ''x'' = 1 and ¬''x'' = 1 if ''x'' = 0. | * NOT ([[negation]]), denoted ¬''x'' (sometimes NOT ''x'', N''x'' or !''x''), satisfies ¬''x'' = 0 if ''x'' = 1 and ¬''x'' = 1 if ''x'' = 0. | ||

Line 71: | Line 90: | ||

</dd> | </dd> | ||

</dl> | </dl> | ||

One may consider that only the negation and one of the two other operations are basic, because of the following identities that allow to define the conjunction in terms of the negation and the disjunction, and vice versa: | One may consider that only the negation and one of the two other operations are basic, because of the following identities that allow to define the conjunction in terms of the negation and the disjunction, and vice versa: | ||

Line 300: | Line 311: | ||

The term "algebra" denotes both a subject, namely the subject of [[algebra]], and an object, namely an [[algebraic structure]]. Whereas the foregoing has addressed the subject of Boolean algebra, this section deals with mathematical objects called Boolean algebras, defined in full generality as any model of the Boolean laws. We begin with a special case of the notion definable without reference to the laws, namely concrete Boolean algebras, and then give [[#Boolean algebras: the definition|the formal definition]] of the general notion. | The term "algebra" denotes both a subject, namely the subject of [[algebra]], and an object, namely an [[algebraic structure]]. Whereas the foregoing has addressed the subject of Boolean algebra, this section deals with mathematical objects called Boolean algebras, defined in full generality as any model of the Boolean laws. We begin with a special case of the notion definable without reference to the laws, namely concrete Boolean algebras, and then give [[#Boolean algebras: the definition|the formal definition]] of the general notion. | ||

==Applications== | ==Applications== | ||

Line 411: | Line 323: | ||

Computers use two-value Boolean circuits for the above reasons. The most common computer architectures use ordered sequences of Boolean values, called bits, of 32 or 64 values, e.g. 01101000110101100101010101001011. When programming in [[machine code]], [[assembly language]], and certain other [[programming languages]], programmers work with the low-level digital structure of the [[Word (data type)|data registers]]. These registers operate on voltages, where zero volts represents Boolean 0, and a reference voltage (often +5V, +3.3V, +1.8V) represents Boolean 1. Such languages support both numeric operations and logical operations. In this context, "numeric" means that the computer treats sequences of bits as [[binary number]]s (base two numbers) and executes arithmetic operations like add, subtract, multiply, or divide. "Logical" refers to the Boolean logical operations of disjunction, conjunction, and negation between two sequences of bits, in which each bit in one sequence is simply compared to its counterpart in the other sequence. Programmers therefore have the option of working in and applying the rules of either numeric algebra or Boolean algebra as needed. A core differentiating feature between these families of operations is the existence of the [[Carry (arithmetic)|carry]] operation in the first but not the second. | Computers use two-value Boolean circuits for the above reasons. The most common computer architectures use ordered sequences of Boolean values, called bits, of 32 or 64 values, e.g. 01101000110101100101010101001011. When programming in [[machine code]], [[assembly language]], and certain other [[programming languages]], programmers work with the low-level digital structure of the [[Word (data type)|data registers]]. These registers operate on voltages, where zero volts represents Boolean 0, and a reference voltage (often +5V, +3.3V, +1.8V) represents Boolean 1. Such languages support both numeric operations and logical operations. In this context, "numeric" means that the computer treats sequences of bits as [[binary number]]s (base two numbers) and executes arithmetic operations like add, subtract, multiply, or divide. "Logical" refers to the Boolean logical operations of disjunction, conjunction, and negation between two sequences of bits, in which each bit in one sequence is simply compared to its counterpart in the other sequence. Programmers therefore have the option of working in and applying the rules of either numeric algebra or Boolean algebra as needed. A core differentiating feature between these families of operations is the existence of the [[Carry (arithmetic)|carry]] operation in the first but not the second. | ||

===Boolean operations=== | ===Boolean operations=== | ||

The original application for Boolean operations was [[mathematical logic]], where it combines the truth values, true or false, of individual formulas. | The original application for Boolean operations was [[mathematical logic]], where it combines the truth values, true or false, of individual formulas. | ||

Line 434: | Line 337: | ||

[[Solid modeling]] systems for [[computer aided design]] offer a variety of methods for building objects from other objects, combination by Boolean operations being one of them. In this method the space in which objects exist is understood as a set ''S'' of [[voxel]]s (the three-dimensional analogue of pixels in two-dimensional graphics) and shapes are defined as subsets of ''S'', allowing objects to be combined as sets via union, intersection, etc. One obvious use is in building a complex shape from simple shapes simply as the union of the latter. Another use is in sculpting understood as removal of material: any grinding, milling, routing, or drilling operation that can be performed with physical machinery on physical materials can be simulated on the computer with the Boolean operation ''x'' ∧ ¬''y'' or ''x'' − ''y'', which in set theory is set difference, remove the elements of ''y'' from those of ''x''. Thus given two shapes one to be machined and the other the material to be removed, the result of machining the former to remove the latter is described simply as their set difference. | [[Solid modeling]] systems for [[computer aided design]] offer a variety of methods for building objects from other objects, combination by Boolean operations being one of them. In this method the space in which objects exist is understood as a set ''S'' of [[voxel]]s (the three-dimensional analogue of pixels in two-dimensional graphics) and shapes are defined as subsets of ''S'', allowing objects to be combined as sets via union, intersection, etc. One obvious use is in building a complex shape from simple shapes simply as the union of the latter. Another use is in sculpting understood as removal of material: any grinding, milling, routing, or drilling operation that can be performed with physical machinery on physical materials can be simulated on the computer with the Boolean operation ''x'' ∧ ¬''y'' or ''x'' − ''y'', which in set theory is set difference, remove the elements of ''y'' from those of ''x''. Thus given two shapes one to be machined and the other the material to be removed, the result of machining the former to remove the latter is described simply as their set difference. | ||

= | = | ||

[[Google Scholar]] appears to perform the XOR operation when the OR keyword is used. | [[Google Scholar]] appears to perform the XOR operation when the OR keyword is used. | ||

--> | --> |

## Revision as of 11:34, 20 July 2018

*Boolean algebra'* is the branch of algebra in which the values of the variables and constants have exactly two values: "true" and "false", usually denoted 1 and 0 respectively. This overview is taken from the Wikipedia article.

The main operations of Boolean algebra are "and" (conjunction), "or" (disjunction), and "not" (negation). The "and" operator says that two variable are true only whenever both variables are true. The "or" operator says that two variables are true whenever either or both variables are true. The "not" operator changes a true to false and a false to true. Just as algebra has basic rules for simplifying and evaluating expression, so does Boolean algebra.

Boolean algebra is important to programmers, computer scientists, and the general population.

- For programmers, Boolean expressions are used for conditionals and loops. For example, the following snippet of code sums the even numbers that are not also multiples of 3, stopping when the sum hits 100:

```
s = 0
x = 1
while (s < 100):
if (x % 2 == 0) and (x % 3 != 0):
s = s + x
x = x + 1
```

Both
`s < 100`

and
`(x % 2 == 0) and (x % 3 != 0)`

are Boolean expressions.

- For computer scientists, Boolean algebra defines the circuits that make up the logic of digital computers.

- The general population uses Boolean algebra, probably without knowing that they are doing so, when they enter search terms in Internet search engines. Google,

for example, suuport AND, OR, and NOT, as well as a handful of shorthands (See e.g.,Syntax cheatsheet,

- Whitespace is used to specify logical AND, as it is the default operator for joining search terms:
- The OR keyword is used for logical OR:
- A prefixed minus sign is used for logical NOT:

For example, the search team jaguar speed -car returns pages about the speed of the Jaquar animal.

"Search term 1" −"Search term 2"

Principle: If {X, R} is a poset, then {X, R(inverse)} is also a poset.

There is nothing magical about the choice of symbols for the values of Boolean algebra. We could rename 0 and 1 to say α and β, and as long as we did so consistently throughout it would still be Boolean algebra, albeit with some obvious cosmetic differences.

But suppose we rename 0 and 1 to 1 and 0 respectively. Then it would still be Boolean algebra, and moreover operating on the same values. However it would not be identical to our original Boolean algebra because now we find ∨ behaving the way ∧ used to do and vice versa. So there are still some cosmetic differences to show that we've been fiddling with the notation, despite the fact that we're still using 0s and 1s.

But if in addition to interchanging the names of the values we also interchange the names of the two binary operations, *now* there is no trace of what we have done. The end product is completely indistinguishable from what we started with. We might notice that the columns for *x*∧*y* and *x*∨*y* in the truth tables had changed places, but that switch is immaterial.

When values and operations can be paired up in a way that leaves everything important unchanged when all pairs are switched simultaneously, we call the members of each pair **dual** to each other. Thus 0 and 1 are dual, and ∧ and ∨ are dual. The **Duality Principle**, also called De Morgan duality, asserts that Boolean algebra is unchanged when all dual pairs are interchanged.

One change we did not need to make as part of this interchange was to complement. We say that complement is a **self-dual** operation. The identity or do-nothing operation *x* (copy the input to the output) is also self-dual. A more complicated example of a self-dual operation is (*x*∧*y*) ∨ (*y*∧*z*) ∨ (*z*∧*x*). There is no self-dual binary operation that depends on both its arguments. A composition of self-dual operations is a self-dual operation. For example, if *f*(*x*, *y*, *z*) = (*x*∧*y*) ∨ (*y*∧*z*) ∨ (*z*∧*x*), then *f*(*f*(*x*, *y*, *z*), *x*, *t*) is a self-dual operation of four arguments *x,y,z,t*.

The principle of duality can be explained from a group theory perspective by the fact that there are exactly four functions that are one-to-one mappings (automorphisms) of the set of Boolean polynomials back to itself: the identity function, the complement function, the dual function and the contradual function (complemented dual). These four functions form a group under function composition, isomorphic to the Klein four-group, acting on the set of Boolean polynomials. Walter Gottschalk remarked that consequently a more appropriate name for the phenomenon would be the *principle* (or *square*) *of quaternality*.<ref name="GivantHalmos2009">Template:Cite book</ref>

## Diagrammatic representations

### Venn diagrams

A Venn diagram<ref>Template:Cite journal [1] [2]</ref> is a representation of a Boolean operation using shaded overlapping regions. There is one region for each variable, all circular in the examples here. The interior and exterior of region *x* corresponds respectively to the values 1 (true) and 0 (false) for variable *x*. The shading indicates the value of the operation for each combination of regions, with dark denoting 1 and light 0 (some authors use the opposite convention).

The three Venn diagrams in the figure below represent respectively conjunction *x*∧*y*, disjunction *x*∨*y*, and complement ¬*x*.

For conjunction, the region inside both circles is shaded to indicate that *x*∧*y* is 1 when both variables are 1. The other regions are left unshaded to indicate that *x*∧*y* is 0 for the other three combinations.

The second diagram represents disjunction *x*∨*y* by shading those regions that lie inside either or both circles. The third diagram represents complement ¬*x* by shading the region *not* inside the circle.

While we have not shown the Venn diagrams for the constants 0 and 1, they are trivial, being respectively a white box and a dark box, neither one containing a circle. However we could put a circle for *x* in those boxes, in which case each would denote a function of one argument, *x*, which returns the same value independently of *x*, called a constant function. As far as their outputs are concerned, constants and constant functions are indistinguishable; the difference is that a constant takes no arguments, called a *zeroary* or *nullary* operation, while a constant function takes one argument, which it ignores, and is a *unary* operation.

Venn diagrams are helpful in visualizing laws. The commutativity laws for ∧ and ∨ can be seen from the symmetry of the diagrams: a binary operation that was not commutative would not have a symmetric diagram because interchanging *x* and *y* would have the effect of reflecting the diagram horizontally and any failure of commutativity would then appear as a failure of symmetry.

Idempotence of ∧ and ∨ can be visualized by sliding the two circles together and noting that the shaded area then becomes the whole circle, for both ∧ and ∨.

To see the first absorption law, *x*∧(*x*∨*y*) = *x*, start with the diagram in the middle for *x*∨*y* and note that the portion of the shaded area in common with the *x* circle is the whole of the *x* circle. For the second absorption law, *x*∨(*x*∧*y*) = *x*, start with the left diagram for *x*∧*y* and note that shading the whole of the *x* circle results in just the *x* circle being shaded, since the previous shading was inside the *x* circle.

The double negation law can be seen by complementing the shading in the third diagram for ¬*x*, which shades the *x* circle.

To visualize the first De Morgan's law, (¬*x*)∧(¬*y*) = ¬(*x*∨*y*), start with the middle diagram for *x*∨*y* and complement its shading so that only the region outside both circles is shaded, which is what the right hand side of the law describes. The result is the same as if we shaded that region which is both outside the *x* circle *and* outside the *y* circle, i.e. the conjunction of their exteriors, which is what the left hand side of the law describes.

The second De Morgan's law, (¬*x*)∨(¬*y*) = ¬(*x*∧*y*), works the same way with the two diagrams interchanged.

The first complement law, *x*∧¬*x* = 0, says that the interior and exterior of the *x* circle have no overlap. The second complement law, *x*∨¬*x* = 1, says that everything is either inside or outside the *x* circle.

### Digital logic gates

Digital logic is the application of the Boolean algebra of 0 and 1 to electronic hardware consisting of logic gates connected to form a circuit diagram. Each gate implements a Boolean operation, and is depicted schematically by a shape indicating the operation. The shapes associated with the gates for conjunction (AND-gates), disjunction (OR-gates), and complement (inverters) are as follows.<ref>Template:Cite journal</ref>

The lines on the left of each gate represent input wires or *ports*. The value of the input is represented by a voltage on the lead. For so-called "active-high" logic, 0 is represented by a voltage close to zero or "ground", while 1 is represented by a voltage close to the supply voltage; active-low reverses this. The line on the right of each gate represents the output port, which normally follows the same voltage conventions as the input ports.

Complement is implemented with an inverter gate. The triangle denotes the operation that simply copies the input to the output; the small circle on the output denotes the actual inversion complementing the input. The convention of putting such a circle on any port means that the signal passing through this port is complemented on the way through, whether it is an input or output port.

The Duality Principle, or De Morgan's laws, can be understood as asserting that complementing all three ports of an AND gate converts it to an OR gate and vice versa, as shown in Figure 4 below. Complementing both ports of an inverter however leaves the operation unchanged.

More generally one may complement any of the eight subsets of the three ports of either an AND or OR gate. The resulting sixteen possibilities give rise to only eight Boolean operations, namely those with an odd number of 1's in their truth table. There are eight such because the "odd-bit-out" can be either 0 or 1 and can go in any of four positions in the truth table. There being sixteen binary Boolean operations, this must leave eight operations with an even number of 1's in their truth tables. Two of these are the constants 0 and 1 (as binary operations that ignore both their inputs); four are the operations that depend nontrivially on exactly one of their two inputs, namely *x*, *y*, ¬*x*, and ¬*y*; and the remaining two are *x*⊕*y* (XOR) and its complement *x*≡*y*.

## Boolean algebras

Template:Main article The term "algebra" denotes both a subject, namely the subject of algebra, and an object, namely an algebraic structure. Whereas the foregoing has addressed the subject of Boolean algebra, this section deals with mathematical objects called Boolean algebras, defined in full generality as any model of the Boolean laws. We begin with a special case of the notion definable without reference to the laws, namely concrete Boolean algebras, and then give the formal definition of the general notion.

## Applications

Boolean algebra as the calculus of two values is fundamental to computer circuits, computer programming, and mathematical logic, and is also used in other areas of mathematics such as set theory and statistics.<ref name="givhal"/>

### Computers

In the early 20th century, several electrical engineers intuitively recognized that Boolean algebra was analogous to the behavior of certain types of electrical circuits. Claude Shannon formally proved such behavior was logically equivalent to Boolean algebra in his 1937 master's thesis, *A Symbolic Analysis of Relay and Switching Circuits*.

Today, all modern general purpose computers perform their functions using two-value Boolean logic; that is, their electrical circuits are a physical manifestation of two-value Boolean logic. They achieve this in various ways: as voltages on wires in high-speed circuits and capacitive storage devices, as orientations of a magnetic domain in ferromagnetic storage devices, as holes in punched cards or paper tape, and so on. (Some early computers used decimal circuits or mechanisms instead of two-valued logic circuits.)

Of course, it is possible to code more than two symbols in any given medium. For example, one might use respectively 0, 1, 2, and 3 volts to code a four-symbol alphabet on a wire, or holes of different sizes in a punched card. In practice, the tight constraints of high speed, small size, and low power combine to make noise a major factor. This makes it hard to distinguish between symbols when there are several possible symbols that could occur at a single site. Rather than attempting to distinguish between four voltages on one wire, digital designers have settled on two voltages per wire, high and low.

Computers use two-value Boolean circuits for the above reasons. The most common computer architectures use ordered sequences of Boolean values, called bits, of 32 or 64 values, e.g. 01101000110101100101010101001011. When programming in machine code, assembly language, and certain other programming languages, programmers work with the low-level digital structure of the data registers. These registers operate on voltages, where zero volts represents Boolean 0, and a reference voltage (often +5V, +3.3V, +1.8V) represents Boolean 1. Such languages support both numeric operations and logical operations. In this context, "numeric" means that the computer treats sequences of bits as binary numbers (base two numbers) and executes arithmetic operations like add, subtract, multiply, or divide. "Logical" refers to the Boolean logical operations of disjunction, conjunction, and negation between two sequences of bits, in which each bit in one sequence is simply compared to its counterpart in the other sequence. Programmers therefore have the option of working in and applying the rules of either numeric algebra or Boolean algebra as needed. A core differentiating feature between these families of operations is the existence of the carry operation in the first but not the second.

### Boolean operations

The original application for Boolean operations was mathematical logic, where it combines the truth values, true or false, of individual formulas.

Natural languages such as English have words for several Boolean operations, in particular conjunction (*and*), disjunction (*or*), negation (*not*), and implication (*implies*). *But not* is synonymous with *and not*. When used to combine situational assertions such as "the block is on the table" and "cats drink milk," which naively are either true or false, the meanings of these logical connectives often have the meaning of their logical counterparts. However, with descriptions of behavior such as "Jim walked through the door", one starts to notice differences such as failure of commutativity, for example the conjunction of "Jim opened the door" with "Jim walked through the door" in that order is not equivalent to their conjunction in the other order, since *and* usually means *and then* in such cases. Questions can be similar: the order "Is the sky blue, and why is the sky blue?" makes more sense than the reverse order. Conjunctive commands about behavior are like behavioral assertions, as in *get dressed and go to school*. Disjunctive commands such *love me or leave me* or *fish or cut bait* tend to be asymmetric via the implication that one alternative is less preferable. Conjoined nouns such as *tea and milk* generally describe aggregation as with set union while *tea or milk* is a choice. However context can reverse these senses, as in *your choices are coffee and tea* which usually means the same as *your choices are coffee or tea* (alternatives). Double negation as in "I don't not like milk" rarely means literally "I do like milk" but rather conveys some sort of hedging, as though to imply that there is a third possibility. "Not not P" can be loosely interpreted as "surely P", and although *P* necessarily implies "not not *P*" the converse is suspect in English, much as with intuitionistic logic. In view of the highly idiosyncratic usage of conjunctions in natural languages, Boolean algebra cannot be considered a reliable framework for interpreting them.

Boolean operations are used in digital logic to combine the bits carried on individual wires, thereby interpreting them over {0,1}. When a vector of *n* identical binary gates are used to combine two bit vectors each of *n* bits, the individual bit operations can be understood collectively as a single operation on values from a Boolean algebra with 2^{n} elements.

Naive set theory interprets Boolean operations as acting on subsets of a given set *X*. As we saw earlier this behavior exactly parallels the coordinate-wise combinations of bit vectors, with the union of two sets corresponding to the disjunction of two bit vectors and so on.

The 256-element free Boolean algebra on three generators is deployed in computer displays based on raster graphics, which use bit blit to manipulate whole regions consisting of pixels, relying on Boolean operations to specify how the source region should be combined with the destination, typically with the help of a third region called the mask. Modern video cards offer all 2^{23} = 256 ternary operations for this purpose, with the choice of operation being a one-byte (8-bit) parameter. The constants SRC = 0xaa or 10101010, DST = 0xcc or 11001100, and MSK = 0xf0 or 11110000 allow Boolean operations such as (SRC^DST)&MSK (meaning XOR the source and destination and then AND the result with the mask) to be written directly as a constant denoting a byte calculated at compile time, 0x60 in the (SRC^DST)&MSK example, 0x66 if just SRC^DST, etc. At run time the video card interprets the byte as the raster operation indicated by the original expression in a uniform way that requires remarkably little hardware and which takes time completely independent of the complexity of the expression.

Solid modeling systems for computer aided design offer a variety of methods for building objects from other objects, combination by Boolean operations being one of them. In this method the space in which objects exist is understood as a set *S* of voxels (the three-dimensional analogue of pixels in two-dimensional graphics) and shapes are defined as subsets of *S*, allowing objects to be combined as sets via union, intersection, etc. One obvious use is in building a complex shape from simple shapes simply as the union of the latter. Another use is in sculpting understood as removal of material: any grinding, milling, routing, or drilling operation that can be performed with physical machinery on physical materials can be simulated on the computer with the Boolean operation *x* ∧ ¬*y* or *x* − *y*, which in set theory is set difference, remove the elements of *y* from those of *x*. Thus given two shapes one to be machined and the other the material to be removed, the result of machining the former to remove the latter is described simply as their set difference.

= Google Scholar appears to perform the XOR operation when the OR keyword is used. -->